The Worst Time to Hire a Workers' Compensation Attorney

Three people who met with me for a free consultation last week all told me that they thought the best time to hire a workers compensation lawyer to help them with their claim was right before they were scheduled for a permanent partial disability evaluation.   Two told me that they had had  free consultations with other attorneys in the past, and those attorneys were not interested in representing them while they were still actively  treating for their injuries.  Those other lawyers told them to come back when they  were finished getting treatment and were ready for  a settlement. The third person had relied on advice from a co-worker who thought that a lawyer was only necessary to obtain the best settlement.  Unfortunately, those three people were given  bad information  on when to hire a lawyer.  The best time to hire a lawyer, after meeting with one you like, is at the beginning of your claim.  Here's why:

1. Get More Legal Service for the Fee You Pay

Most attorneys charge a contingency fee from the permanent partial disability award at the end of the claim.  That fee  is  usually the same regardless of whether you hire the lawyer at the beginning of your claim, or right before you have the evaluation to determine your settlement.  If you hire a lawyer who actually provides a valuable service in assisting you on your claim each step of the way, you get more legal service for the attorney fee by hiring the attorney at the beginning of your claim.   If an attorney is only interested in representing you at the end of your claim, that is a red flag, and should alert you that the attorney is only wanting a quick fee for providing very little help. 

2. A Work Comp Attorney Should Guide You Each Step on Your Claim

If you hire a lawyer who is committed to helping you on your claim, and is not solely interested in getting his fee from the settlement, you have someone who is experienced in selecting the best doctors for your care.  You also have someone to make sure that your benefit checks are the correct and highest amount, and that they are paid on time.  An experienced work comp lawyer will also guide you through any employment issues while you are treating, and will get a jump start on the retraining process if it appears that the client will not be able to return to her old job. 

3. The Most Important Decisions Are Made at the Beginning of the Claim

The most important service I provide as a workers compensation lawyer is making sure that my clients get the best possible medical care as quickly as possible.  My clients are normal, honest, hard-working people who like their jobs.  They just want to get their injuries fixed and to get back to work and their regular lives. It  is at the beginning of the claim that injured workers decide whether they need a specialist, whether they want to change doctors, whether to have surgery, whether to have a second opinion, and what other treatment options are available.   The beginning of the claim is when insurers deny additional body parts on the claim and deny treatment or surgeries that your doctor requests.  Insurers will  try to usurp control over what happens to the injured worker's body at the beginning of the claim.

4. The Best Lawyers Practice Preventative Law

It is always easier to prevent a problem from happening on a claim than it is to try to fix a problem that has happened.  By the time most injured workers consult with a lawyer on their claim, they have spent many frustrating  months  trying to handle problems by themselves. Injured workers are at a terrible disadvantage when dealing with adjusters, because injured workers do not know what their rights are and whether the adjuster is acting properly on their claim.    A lot can go wrong very quickly, and the time to file an appeal on any determination made by the insurer is only 70 days.

5. What to Do If You Have Waited Until the End of Your Claim

If you have tried to go it alone on your claim, are fed up, and want to hire a lawyer now because you are concerned about the settlement process, get a free consultation with an attorney. You might be able to negotiate a lower attorney fee if you are just about to get a rating evaluation , and  you don't have ongoing problems or potential future problems with your claim. . Be sure to ask whether the attorney will be attending the rating with you.  Also ask whether the attorney will be helping you with any vocational rehabilitation issues, and whether the attorney will be available in the future to help you reopen your claim for more medical care.  Find out whether an actual attorney is handling your claim, particularly if you hire a celebrity attorney law firm.  You might also ask whether the attorney is able to predict  what your percentage of impairment should be.  Those attorneys who are honest and who care about their reputations among injured workers will give you a straight answer.  Finally, there is a ton of information about the rating process in my blogs and on my website.  

Get Well Again Soon!

 

Tags:

Injured Workers Are Stuck with Their Attorneys' Negligence

My office receives at least one phone call a week from an injured worker who is unhappy with how their attorney handled their contested case at a hearing.  Unfortunately, it is usually too late for me to help those callers.  A recent decision from the Nevada Supreme Court illustrates one reason why it is too late for me to help. 

Kathy Garcia, an employee of Scolari's Food & Drug in northern Nevada, filed an occupational disease claim, asking for medical care for pain in her arms and shoulder that she thought was aggravated by her work duties.  Her claim was denied.  Garcia's lawyer decided not to use medical reports at the appeals hearing that might have helped Garcia win her appeal, and Garcia lost her case.  Garcia then asked a  district court to send her case back for another appeals hearing so that she could use the medical reports while acting as her own attorney. 

The Nevada Supreme Court decided against Garcia, with a majority of the justices ruling that any negligence of Garcia's attorney in not putting the reports into evidence did not amount to a "good reason" to remand the case for another hearing.  Two dissenting justices disagreed and wrote that an injured worker should get their day in court with all relevant evidence if they can show that their attorney was negligent.  Garcia v. Scolari's Food & Drug, 125 Nev. Adv. Op. 6 (1/29/09).  The moral of this story is that an injured worker needs to be careful when  selecting an attorney.  

5 Reasons Not to Hire a Work Comp Lawyer

1. You aren’t the type to hire a lawyer

Let’s say you are concerned that you might not be getting all benefits that are or could be owed to you under your claim. Most lawyers offer free consultations, and you can even have consultations with several different attorneys to compare information given by each. Whatever you say is confidential, even if you don’t hire the lawyer. If you then decide that you do need a lawyer to help you on your claim, look for a lawyer who doesn’t seem like the stereotypical attorney type. Can you see yourself in public with this person, having a cup of coffee? Is this someone you can talk freely to, and someone you feel you can trust? Does the attorney speak in simple terms that all people can understand? Trust your gut instincts. If the attorney seems like he or she is not the type to be an attorney, but seems more like a down-to-earth, genuine person, then that may be the attorney for you if you need one. .

2. You don’t want to sue your employer

Good, because you can’t sue your employer for a work injury under Nevada law unless you can prove that your employer intentionally injured you. A work comp attorney is instead assuring that you are given all benefits under the law. If not, the attorney may involve the insurer for your employer in contested appeals, but the employer is not sued.

3. You don’t want to get fired

An employer in Nevada is not likely to subject themself to a lawsuit by firing the injured worker just for hiring an attorney to represent them on the work comp claim. In fact, in over 15 years of representing injured workers, I’ve never seen it happen. Instead, the injured worker is less likely to get fired because he or she has an attorney advising them regarding employment situations during the time the claim is open, and the employer in turn is more careful in how it deals with the employee.

4. Your adjuster seems nice

Many adjusters are nice people, and many are underpaid and overworked with too many claims to handle properly. Your adjuster works for the third-party administrator (TPA) hired by the insurer for your employer. TPA’s get business by showing insurers that they save money processing claims. Your adjuster is simply not going to be advising you when you should be asking for more benefits or looking out for your best interests. It’s not their job.

5. You don’t think you need one

Maybe you don’t need one, but it wouldn’t hurt to take advantage of a free consultation to have an attorney look at the letters sent from the adjuster and advise you whether it appears that you are getting all benefits you are entitled to. At least obtain whatever free information is offered so that you can better inform yourself about the law and your rights.